Retrofit projects rarely fail because of code. They fail because boundary conditions were never pinned down before work started. The eight items below follow the order a real project moves in, and each one states what "clear enough" actually means.
1. Workpiece and process window
Work from physical samples, not drawings. Confirm material and surface treatment (they drive gripping method and wear), weight and centre of gravity, dimensional tolerance range (it decides whether mechanical locating is viable), and whether incoming orientation is consistent.
Test of clarity: can you describe the worst-case incoming part? If the answer is "roughly this size", you will end up adding vision or a feeding mechanism, and the cost structure changes completely.
2. Cycle time and capacity
Cycle time is set by the bottleneck station, not by the robot. Calculate available time per part divided by target output to get the allowed cycle, then sum every motion (pick, transfer, place, return, wait). What remains is your buffer.
Three losses are routinely omitted: coupling waits between machine and robot, changeover and line-clearing time, and stoppages and speed loss inside overall equipment effectiveness. Leave them out and the estimate will be optimistic.
3. How to specify accuracy
Separate absolute accuracy from repeatability in writing. Most pick-and-place work only needs repeatability. Trajectory work — grinding, dispensing, welding — needs absolute and path accuracy, which requires on-site calibration; that cost belongs in the quote.
Agree the measurement method and temperature condition too. The same machine measures differently in a climate-controlled hall and on an open shop floor, so acceptance criteria must state the conditions.
4. End effector and tooling
Gripper, vacuum, force control, quick change — four options matched to incoming-part consistency. Consistent parts favour fixed tooling as the cheapest route. Inconsistent parts need either a compliant gripper or vision. Quick change pays off where changeovers are frequent; where they are rare it only adds failure points.
5. Site power and compressed air
The question is not whether power exists but what the voltage fluctuation range is, how the site is earthed, whether heavy loads start and stop on the same circuit, and how stable air pressure and dew point are. Voltage swings and moisture in the air line are the two most common sources of interference during commissioning, and they are expensive to chase later.
6. Safety and compliance
Work from a risk assessment rather than instinctive fencing. Confirm operator distance, whether light curtains or safety mats are needed, whether the emergency stop circuit is dual-channel, whether safety doors interlock with robot enabling, and whether collaborative force and power limits are configured for the actual task.
Write the responsibility boundary into the contract: the OEM owns robot safety, the integrator assesses risks introduced by tooling and programs, and the user implements operating rules and training. Without this, post-incident allocation becomes very hard.
7. Line communication and data
Confirm the PLC brand and available protocols (Modbus TCP, Profinet, EtherCAT, OPC UA and so on), then confirm where data must go — local HMI only, or into MES. Quoting MES integration for a local-only job, or the reverse, is how scope gets out of control.
8. Acceptance criteria and documents
Quantify each acceptance item in the contract: cycle time, success rate, continuous run duration, measured accuracy, and recovery behaviour after faults. Keep the document list fixed: electrical drawings, pneumatic diagrams, program backups with version notes, operation manual, maintenance manual, spare parts list, training records.
State what warranty covers and what it does not (misuse, consumables, non-original modifications). Recommend stock levels for wear parts so a line never waits on a component.
Once these eight are settled, scope, cost structure and acceptance language are essentially fixed. Leave any of them vague and it returns later as a change order.